OCT 13 | When Success Fails: What a Professional Fisherman's Worst Night Teaches Us About Trusting God with Our Careers
Have you ever experienced the unique sting of failing at the one thing you're actually good at? Not struggling with something new—that's expected. But bombing spectacularly at your area of expertise? That's a different kind of painful.
This is exactly where we find Peter in Luke chapter 5, and what happens next completely transforms how we think about career, calling, and who's really in control of our professional lives.
The Setup: When Expertise Meets Empty Nets
Luke 5:1 sets the scene beside the Sea of Galilee—which, fun fact, isn't actually a sea at all. It's a lake. But in first-century Israel, if a body of water was bigger than your house, you called it a sea and moved on with your life.
Jesus is teaching, and massive crowds are pressing in on Him. They're desperate to hear this rabbi who's been healing people and teaching with genuine authority. He spots two fishing boats at the water's edge, and the fishermen—Peter, Andrew, James, and John—are washing their nets.
Now, this detail matters more than you might think. In first-century fishing culture, washing your nets wasn't prep work for the next shift. It was what you did when you were completely done for the day. Think of it as the ancient equivalent of shutting down your computer, turning off your office lights, and clocking out. These guys weren't getting ready to work—they were wrapping up after a long, frustrating, and completely unsuccessful night.
A night with no catch didn't just mean disappointment. It meant no income. No food to sell. No money to feed their families. These weren't hobbyist fishermen who fished for fun on weekends. This was their livelihood, their family business, their entire economic reality.
When Jesus Interrupts Your Plans
Jesus gets into Peter's boat—verse 3 tells us this—and asks him to put out a little from shore so He can teach the crowd from the boat. And Peter does it. Why not? His night's already been a disaster. He's got nothing else to do. At least he can be helpful in some small way.
Jesus teaches the crowd. We don't get the content of this particular sermon, but knowing Jesus, it probably had something to do with the kingdom of God being closer and more accessible than people realized.
Then comes the moment that changes everything. Verse 4: Jesus turns to Peter and says, "Put out into the deep water and let down your nets for a catch."
We read that sentence quickly, maybe thinking, "Oh, how nice. Jesus is helping with the fishing." But put yourself in Peter's waterlogged boots for a moment.
The Audacity of Divine Instruction
This is like being a seasoned IT professional who's spent twelve hours trying to fix a critical server problem, and someone from marketing walks in at the end of your shift and cheerfully suggests, "Did you try turning it off and on again?"
Or imagine you're a professional chef who's spent all night perfecting a complex dish that just won't come together, and someone who microwaves everything tells you, "Maybe try adding more salt?"
Peter had just worked the entire night. And not just any night—the PRIME fishing time in Galilee. Every professional fisherman knew that night fishing was when you caught fish because the fish came to the surface in cooler temperatures. Daytime fishing? That's when fish go deep where it's cooler. This wasn't a matter of opinion or fishing philosophy. It was basic, universally acknowledged fishing knowledge.
And here was Jesus—a carpenter from Nazareth, a landlocked town twenty miles inland—giving fishing advice to a professional fisherman. The audacity should not be lost on us.
The Response That Changes Everything
Watch Peter's response carefully in verse 5. This single sentence is absolutely everything:
"Master, we've worked hard all night and haven't caught anything."
That's not argument. That's not disrespect or pushback. That's a professional respectfully stating the facts. "I'm the expert here. This is literally my job. I know these waters. I know these fish. And I just tried exactly what you're suggesting. For hours. With nothing to show for it."
You can almost hear the exhaustion in his voice. The frustration. The disappointment of a wasted night and an empty income.
But then—and this is where Peter demonstrates something profound—he adds: "But because you say so, I will let down the nets."
The Greek word Luke uses here is "rhema"—"your word." Not "because it makes logical sense." Not "because I see your reasoning." Not "because I've thought about it and maybe you're right."
Simply: "Because YOU said it."
This is Peter making a deliberate choice to trust Jesus's authority over his own expertise, experience, and professional judgment.
The Miracle That Reveals Everything
So they go out. They lower the nets in the worst possible conditions for catching fish. And verse 6 describes what happens next: they caught "such a large number of fish that their nets began to break."
Not just a decent catch. Not "oh, we got enough for dinner." Their professional-grade fishing nets—built to handle substantial loads—started literally tearing apart from the weight of the fish.
They had to frantically signal to their partners in the other boat to come help. Both boats got so completely full of fish that they began to sink. The boats themselves couldn't handle the abundance.
These professional fishermen, who knew these waters intimately, who had generational knowledge about fishing in Galilee, who had every advantage of experience and expertise, just had the catch of their lives in the exact conditions that shouldn't have produced anything at all.
The Unexpected Reaction to Abundance
Here's where the story takes a surprising turn, and this is what we almost always miss:
Peter doesn't celebrate. He doesn't high-five James. He doesn't start calculating profit margins or thinking about how this windfall will set them up for months. He doesn't do what we'd expect successful people to do when they finally hit it big.
Look at verse 8: "When Simon Peter saw this, he fell at Jesus's knees and said, 'Go away from me, Lord; I am a sinful man!'"
Wait. What?
Why does a miracle catch—an answered need, divine provision, professional success—make Peter feel sinful?
Because in that moment, Peter realized something that was simultaneously terrifying and wonderful: This man standing in his boat had complete authority over Peter's entire livelihood. Over his career. Over the fish. Over the laws of nature. Over everything Peter thought he controlled.
And if Jesus had that much control over Peter's world, then Peter had far, far less control than he'd believed his entire life.
Missing the Mark
The Greek word Peter uses here—"hamartolos," translated as "sinful"—carries more meaning than just "I did bad things." It has the connotation of "missing the mark," like an archer whose arrow falls short of the target.
In that moment, Peter realized he'd been aiming at the wrong target his entire life. He'd built his identity on being a successful fisherman. He'd placed his trust in his own competence, his own knowledge, his own hard work, his own ability to provide for his family through his professional skills.
And Jesus just demonstrated that all of it—every bit of it—could change in an instant.
Peter's security was an illusion. His control was imaginary. His professional expertise, while real and valuable, wasn't the source of his provision. It never had been.
That's a terrifying realization. And it's also incredibly freeing.
Redirected, Not Rejected
Jesus's response in verse 10 is beautiful: "Don't be afraid; from now on you will fish for people."
The Greek word for "catch" here—"zogreo"—literally means "to catch alive." Not destructive catching. Not catching that kills. Life-giving catching.
Jesus isn't saying, "Peter, your skills were useless. Your career was a waste. Everything you've learned doesn't matter."
He's saying, "Peter, I'm not taking your skills away. I'm redirecting them. You're still going to use everything you know about patience, persistence, reading conditions, timing, working with a team, handling rejection, persevering through long nights. But now? Now you're going to do it for something that lasts forever."
The Pattern of Redemptive Redirection
This is the same pattern we see throughout Scripture:
Moses—a shepherd who spent forty years leading sheep through wilderness—becomes the leader who guides millions of people through the wilderness to the Promised Land.
David—a shepherd boy who protected sheep from lions and bears—becomes the king who protects Israel from enemies.
Matthew—a tax collector who understood money, accounting, and detailed record-keeping—becomes the gospel writer who meticulously documents Jesus's fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies.
Paul—a Pharisee trained in rigorous theological debate and Scripture knowledge—becomes the missionary who establishes churches and writes theological letters to them.
God doesn't waste your experience. He doesn't nullify your training. He doesn't make your career meaningless.
He redirects it toward eternal purposes.
What This Means for Your Career Right Now
You might be in a season where you've fished all night and caught nothing. You've done everything right professionally. You've worked hard. You've applied your expertise. You've followed best practices. And it feels like none of it is working.
Your business isn't growing like you planned. Your career isn't advancing like you hoped. Your efforts aren't producing the results you expected. Your skills aren't translating into success.
And maybe—just maybe—God is about to ask you to do something that doesn't make professional sense.
Something that goes against your training. Something that contradicts your experience. Something that challenges your professional judgment.
When God asks you to "put out into deep water" in your career, He's not ignoring your expertise. He's not being cruel or capricious. He's not playing games with your livelihood.
He's showing you something crucial that you need to understand: Your success has never been just about your competence. It's always been about His provision.
The Terrifying Freedom of Surrender
When you really grasp this—when it moves from your head to your heart—it's both terrifying and incredibly freeing.
It's terrifying because it means you're not in control. Your success or failure doesn't ultimately depend on your skills, your networking, your strategy, or your effort. That's scary for those of us who like to feel in charge of our destinies.
But it's also profoundly freeing because it means:
Your worth isn't tied to your performance. Your identity isn't in your job title. Your security isn't in your skills. Your provision isn't dependent solely on your competence.
It's in the One who controls the fish.
The One who can produce abundance in impossible conditions. The One who can redirect your career toward eternal significance. The One who sees your empty nets and asks you to trust Him anyway.
Obedience Without Guaranteed Outcomes
Now, let me be clear: I'm not saying quit your job tomorrow and wait for miracles to happen. That's not the lesson here.
Peter didn't sit on the shore and wait for fish to jump into his boat. He still had to put out into deep water. He still had to let down the nets. He still had to do the physical work of fishing.
But he did it with a completely different posture: "Because You say so."
Not "because I see how this will work out." Not "because I've calculated the odds and they're favorable." Not "because this makes strategic sense."
Simply: "Because You say so."
That's the difference between striving and obedience. Between anxiety and trust. Between self-reliance and God-dependence.
Your Deep Water Moment
So what's your version of "fishing in daylight"?
What is God asking you to do in your career, your calling, your work life that doesn't make professional sense but makes obedience sense?
Maybe it's staying in a job that doesn't pay as much as you could make elsewhere because you know you're supposed to be there.
Maybe it's leaving a career that looks successful on paper because you know it's killing your soul and distancing you from God.
Maybe it's starting something new that terrifies you because you've never done it before and have no guarantee of success.
Maybe it's saying no to an opportunity that everyone tells you is perfect but doesn't bring you peace.
Maybe it's pivoting your business in a direction that seems risky but won't leave your conscience.
Maybe it's using your professional skills in ministry contexts that don't advance your career but advance the kingdom.
Whatever it is—do it because He says so.
Not because you see the full picture. Not because it makes sense to everyone around you. Not because you're guaranteed a miracle catch.
Because He says so.
The Invitation to Trust
This story invites us into a fundamentally different way of approaching our careers and callings. It's an invitation to see our work—whatever it is—as a place where we can practice trust, demonstrate obedience, and participate in something bigger than professional success.
It's an invitation to hold our expertise humbly, acknowledging that the One who created fish and water and the laws of nature might occasionally ask us to operate outside conventional wisdom.
It's an invitation to measure success not just by income, advancement, or recognition, but by faithfulness to what God is asking us to do right now, even when it seems counterintuitive.
And it's an invitation to watch what He does with our nets when we're willing to cast them where He directs, not just where our experience suggests.
Because here's what Peter discovered: When you put your nets down in obedience to Jesus, even in conditions that shouldn't work, you might just experience a catch so big that it tears your nets and sinks your boat.
And that moment of abundance won't just change your career.
It'll change your entire understanding of who's really been providing for you all along.
An Invitation to go Deeper….
If today’s message spoke to you, join the FaithLabz 30-Day Prayer Challenge and strengthen your connection with God’s unshakable love. You are never alone—let’s grow together!
